Solar Power

Negative prices at midday: what they actually mean

17 November 2026 · by Priya Nair
7 min read·1535 words·Updated 17 Nov 2026

Check AEMO’s dashboard most sunny days around 11am to 2pm on a mild day in spring or autumn and you’ll find swathes of the NEM sitting below zero, sometimes well below it. South Australia will often be the worst offender, Victoria not far behind, and on the right day even Queensland joins in. This isn’t a system fault. It’s the grid telling you, in the bluntest language it has, that there’s more electricity around than anyone wants right now.

I get calls about this from clients who’ve started watching their retailer app a bit too closely. They see a negative number next to “wholesale price” and assume something’s broken, or that someone’s about to send them a bill for the privilege of exporting. Neither is quite right, though the second one isn’t as far off as it used to be, and that’s really the story.

What a negative price actually represents #

Think of the grid as a single tank that has to stay exactly full, all the time, every five minutes. Too little water and the lights flicker; too much and something has to give. Around midday on a mild, sunny day, rooftop solar and large-scale solar farms are both pumping in at once, demand is relatively soft because people are at work or school rather than running air conditioners, and there isn’t enough flexible load or storage soaking up the extra. A negative price is the market’s way of paying someone – a battery, a pumped hydro scheme, an industrial user with a flexible process – to take electricity off the grid’s hands rather than let supply run over the top of demand.

The AEMO five-minute dispatch engine sets this price by matching bids and demand in real time, and generators can genuinely offer at negative prices if they’d rather pay to keep running than shut down and restart later. AEMO’s own market data shows this isn’t a rare event any more; it’s become a routine feature of the middle of the day across several states, not an edge case. I’ve written before about how the five-minute dispatch mechanism actually works, and it’s worth understanding that the price isn’t set by some tariff schedule. It’s set every five minutes by whoever’s willing to run cheapest, or least expensively leave the market.

Rooftop solar is both the cause and a casualty #

Here’s the bit that’s genuinely awkward for an installer to explain to a client who’s just spent money putting panels on their roof: the fleet of rooftop solar that’s now pushing past the 24-gigawatt mark nationally is itself a major contributor to the midday glut. I’ve covered this tension in more detail in a piece on whether rooftop solar is quietly breaking the grid, and the negative-price pattern is really the price signal version of that same minimum-demand problem.

When wholesale prices go negative, that’s the market absorbing the cost of oversupply somewhere. Increasingly, “somewhere” means household feed-in tariffs. A growing number of retailers now apply negative or zero feed-in tariffs during designated midday windows, meaning your export isn’t earning you anything, and on some plans it can actually cost you a small amount per kilowatt-hour sent back. This isn’t retailers being stingy for the sake of it. It reflects a wholesale price that’s gone negative, and a retailer passing that signal through rather than eating the loss themselves.

Export limits are the switchboard-level version of this problem #

On the ground, this shows up as export limits: the cap a distributor sets on how much a household system can push back into the local network, often somewhere between 1.5 and 10 kilowatts depending on the suburb and the transformer serving it. I size a lot of residential strings now assuming the export limit, not the inverter’s maximum output, is the real constraint. A 10-kilowatt system with a 5-kilowatt export cap isn’t broken; it’s just been told the local wires can’t take more than that without local voltage climbing too high, which trips other people’s inverters off before it trips yours.

Negative wholesale prices and tight export limits are two sides of the same coin. One is the price signal for too much supply at a market level; the other is the physical constraint at a street level. A transformer on a quiet suburban feeder, built decades ago for a handful of air conditioners and kettles, wasn’t engineered to carry fifteen houses all pushing solar back through it at once. That’s not a policy failure so much as infrastructure built for a different grid meeting a very different grid than the one it’s now serving.

Where the flexible demand is supposed to come from #

The theoretical fix for midday oversupply is to either store the excess or shift demand into that window. Big batteries do some of this – charging cheap or even being paid to take power at midday, then discharging into the evening peak when prices are usually strongly positive. Hornsdale and the growing fleet Neoen Australia operates do exactly this kind of arbitrage, and it’s become one of the more reliable revenue streams for grid-scale storage, more dependable in some ways than the frequency control services that first made big batteries famous.

Home batteries do the same thing at a much smaller scale, and this is genuinely one of the better arguments for installing one right now, better than the glossy payback calculators retailers hand out. If your system is already hitting an export limit or facing a zero feed-in tariff at midday, a battery isn’t competing with a feed-in tariff that’s already worth something. It’s competing with a feed-in tariff that’s worth nothing. I’ve gone through the real numbers on home battery payback elsewhere, and the midday export problem is one of the few places where the case genuinely strengthens rather than weakens once you look closely.

Virtual power plants are the other lever, aggregating thousands of home batteries and smart appliances to respond to these price signals automatically rather than relying on someone checking an app. The honest state of play is that VPP enrolment numbers are growing but still cover a modest share of the fleet with batteries installed, and the orchestration software hasn’t fully caught up with the ambition.

The industrial side nobody really talks about #

Negative prices are also a quiet subsidy for anyone with a flexible industrial process. An aluminium smelter, a desalination plant, a hydrogen electrolyser, anything that can run its energy-hungry process during the cheap or negative window and pause during the expensive evening peak, stands to benefit enormously. This is part of why green hydrogen keeps getting pitched as a sponge for surplus renewable generation, soaking up the midday glut that would otherwise go to waste or get curtailed. Whether hydrogen electrolysis actually makes commercial sense at scale in Australia remains a genuinely open question, and I’d point anyone interested at the more sober assessments of where green hydrogen actually stacks up rather than the investor-deck version.

My own contrarian view, for what it’s worth: I think negative prices are a feature we should be designing around more deliberately, rather than treating as a temporary nuisance to be engineered away with more storage. A grid with abundant cheap midday power and expensive evening power is a grid with a very clear price signal about when to run the dishwasher, charge the EV, or heat the hot water tank. The AEMC’s ongoing work on tariff reform and the push toward more cost-reflective network pricing is trying to get households and businesses to actually respond to that signal, rather than ignore it because most bills are still flat-rate.

What this means for the household on the roof #

On the numbers, a household with a 6.6-kilowatt system and a standard feed-in tariff plan is probably losing very little from midday negative pricing directly, because most retailers still smooth the impact into an annual average rate rather than passing through five-minute wholesale swings. But if your retailer has moved you onto a time-varying feed-in tariff, which more are doing, the midday window is where your export income is being quietly squeezed. Check your plan’s feed-in schedule, not just the headline rate advertised when you signed up.

I lost a basil plant to overwatering back in spring, which tells you nothing about electricity markets except that timing matters more than volume, in gardens and in grids alike. Too much of anything delivered at the wrong moment is still a problem, even when the thing itself is free.

The practical advice I give clients hasn’t changed much: size your export expectations around the limit your distributor actually allows, not the inverter nameplate; ask your retailer for the specific hours their feed-in tariff drops to zero or negative before you sign; and if you’re adding a battery, model it against what midday exports are actually worth on your plan today, not the number from two years ago. The Clean Energy Regulator’s data on rooftop solar capacity additions shows the fleet keeps growing regardless of any of this, which means the midday glut isn’t going away. The question is whether the grid gets better at using it, or households keep eating the cost of a problem they only partly caused.

– Priya Nair, Solar & Distributed Energy Correspondent

Photo by American Public Power Association on Unsplash